Retiring on dividends requires balancing attractive yields with safety and growth to ensure sustainable, inflation-beating income over time. Many investors are shooting themselves in the foot with these 3 dividend traps. We detail how to avoid these dividend traps and instead build a sustainable dividend portfolio for retirement.
Judging by the latest dividend declarations, profit growth of SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) faces pressure, while valuation risks are elevated. SPY's current implied volatility (IV) underestimates these issues. I don't expect SPY's IV to remain muted for long given the many ongoing geopolitical conflicts both globally and domestically in the U.S.
Pacer Metaurus US Large Cap Dividend Multiplier 400 ETF is rated a Buy, while JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF is rated as a Hold. QDPL offers a unique structure, delivering approximately 4x the S&P 500 yield via exposure to S&P Dividend Futures, outperforming JEPI in yield. JEPI uses equity-linked notes and covered call strategies for income, but QDPL's methodology provides superior income potential without sacrificing total return.
Falling interest rates and lower volatility could help JEPI reduce realized losses, but they also shrink option premiums, directly reducing the fund's income potential. Investors withdrawing 4.9% annually from SPY or 5.8% annually from QQQ would still match the ending total returns portfolio value of JEPI - indicating silent wealth erosion. By consistently selling 30-delta options, JEPI exposes itself to frequent in-the-money finishes. This approach systematically amplifies realized losses while capping upside.
The S&P 500 is wandering into uncharted territory as it looks to wander above the 6,500 mark going into the last four months of the year.
Key Points in This Article: High-yield ETFs balance attractive income with diversification to reduce risks tied to chasing unsustainable dividends.
GPIX's dynamic overwrite approach captures more S&P 500 upside, minimizes NAV erosion risk, and delivers robust total returns, versus JEPI. JEPI offers downside protection, with a defensive portfolio, but its upside capture is limited and NAV recovery lags materially in bull markets. GPIX is significantly more tax-efficient for taxable accounts, with favorable 60/40 capital gains treatment and return of capital distributions.
JEPI remains a solid income-focused ETF, but recent performance lags behind newer, innovative competitors in both yield and capital appreciation. I am downgrading my rating on JEPI from very bullish to neutral due to its underperformance versus alternatives like SPYI, QQQI, and QDVO. While I still hold JEPI for its income, I am not adding to my position until it demonstrates improved returns relative to peers.
JEPI offers high monthly income and lower volatility, making it ideal for investors seeking stability and predictable cash flow over aggressive growth. The ETF combines actively selected large-cap US equities with systematic covered call strategies, resulting in a defensive, income-focused portfolio. While JEPI lags the S&P 500 in bull markets, its structure cushions downside risk and maintains stable yields, appealing to income-oriented investors.
SPY is at record highs with stretched valuations and heavy tech concentration, signaling elevated risk and potential for a market correction. A simple risk management strategy is to rotate to JEPI, a covered call ETF offering income and a more balanced sector exposure. JEPI has historically outperformed SPY during drawdowns, smoothing volatility and providing an 8.3% dividend yield, making it a strong defensive play.
I am downgrading JEPI from Hold to Sell due to persistent underperformance versus the S&P 500 and peer covered-call ETFs. JEPI's rigid options strategy limits upside capture and exposes investors to downside, while GPIX and SPYI use more flexible, nuanced approaches. Although JEPI reliably delivers an 8% yield, its total returns lag behind GPIX and SPYI, which also generate comparable income.
With its recent dividend declarations, JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF's current yield has dropped below its historical average. With VIX expected to remain calm, I anticipate JEPI's yield will likely stay below average in the near term. On the positive side, JEPI's proprietary screening algorithm and option overlay offer some downside protection and help mitigate S&P 500 valuation risks.