NI Holdings offers unique windfall opportunities for shareholders from either a full demutualization or a remutualisation. Anti-dilution provisions from the 2017 IPO could result in significant gains for current shareholders upon full demutualization. The company's performance was adversely impacted in 2024 due to challenging operating conditions.
American Family Insurance is selling its non-standard auto insurance business to Sentry Insurance, signaling the potential for more mutual insurance deals. NI Holdings, Inc. is undervalued, trading at 75% of FCTBV, and has failed to justify its public existence with poor financial performance. The company should remutualize, potentially selling to a mutual insurance company for around $27.50 per share, benefiting all stakeholders.