Andrew Beer, Founder & Managing Member at Dynamic Beta Investments and Nate Geraci, President of Novadius Wealth Management discuss how this previsouly niche part of the market is emerging as a force against volatility.
The Simplify Managed Futures Strategy ETF (CTA) has undergone a major strategy and management shift, now managed in-house by Simplify. CTA has transitioned from a diversified, multi-asset managed futures approach to a hyperfocused, leveraged long exposure in energy commodities, with minimal short positions. The abrupt strategy change and lack of transparency have led me to downgrade CTA from strong buy to hold, citing uncertainty and risk to portfolio stability.
The Simplify Managed Futures Strategy ETF offers diversified, actively managed futures exposure with low equity correlation, suitable for hedging across market cycles. CTA provides monthly distributions and 1099 tax reporting, though distribution rates have declined and vary due to market volatility. With a 0.75% expense ratio and $1.63B in assets, CTA is best suited for long-term, alternative sleeve allocations rather than active trading.
Halfway through the year, the U.S. equity market performance is broadening. That said, market concentration remains incredibly high, while equity and bond correlations sit in positive territory — conditions that scream a call for diversification.
Simplify Managed Futures Strategy ETF remains a Hold, serving as a volatility buffer rather than a market-beating capital appreciation vehicle. CTA's strength lies in low equity correlation and downside risk management, especially during risk-off events and market declines. Recent NAV losses and underperformance stem from rapid trend reversals in commodities, notably oil, exposing the model's lag in adapting to new trends.
Simplify Managed Futures Strategy ETF is rated a buy for its robust non-correlated return profile and seasoned sub-advisor, Altis Partners. CTA's 5Y beta of –0.31 and concentrated Euro fixed income exposure offer meaningful diversification for equity- and credit-heavy portfolios. The fund structurally benefits from T-bill collateral, generating about 280 bps of return before trading P&L, supporting a 6.2% distribution rate.
Most diversification strategies fail exactly when investors need them most. In the 2022 bear market, bonds and stocks fell together, leaving the traditional 60/40 portfolio with nowhere to hide.
The Simplify Managed Futures Strategy ETF offers stable and substantive income without excessive risk. This fund has shown to have a strategy that works even in more adverse market conditions. CTA is not correlated with equities, this income-investment should continue to offer consistent payouts even if volatility levels rise.
Simplify Managed Futures Strategy ETF is a solid 'managed futures' ETF, sporting a robust track record of positive total returns through market drawdowns. With little exposure to traditional market correlations, it's a proven hedge. We think it's a superior option to bonds, which have failed in this role as of late. As markets become more correlated, options like CTA add meaningful diversification to your portfolio. We rate CTA a 'Buy'.
CTA is an actively-managed, multi-asset class, long-short futures ETF. The fund has outperformed its managed futures peers since inception, slightly underperformed the S&P 500. Risk and volatility are somewhat complicated, but the fund could serve to decrease risk at the portfolio level.
The Simplify Managed Futures Strategy ETF uses a quantitative model for managed futures, aiming for absolute returns with low correlation to equities and support in risk-off events. The fund's trend-following strategy, complemented by non-trend models and the carry factor, helps achieve diversification and improved risk/reward characteristics. Despite a 0.76% expense ratio, the ETF's complex strategies and access to unique instruments justify its cost for long-term portfolio diversification.
Weaker-than-expected services PMI, declining home sales, and deteriorating consumer confidence triggered fears of slowing growth, amplifying a market downturn triggered by a $2.7 trillion options expiration. Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and JPMorgan estimate recession probabilities between 15-35%, suggesting that while economic growth is slowing, a severe downturn remains unlikely. This portfolio combines a high-yield covered-call ETF (JEPI), a deep-value ETF (VFLO), a hyper-growth ETF (MGK), and a managed futures ETF (CTA) to provide a 6% yield with 47% lower volatility.